best rooftop luggage carrier

Standing in pouring rain, I realized why a truly waterproof rooftop luggage carrier matters. After testing several options, I found that durability, water resistance, and security are the top priorities. When driving through storms or rough terrain, a carrier that can handle the elements without leaks or tears saves you from headaches and ruined gear.

Of all the products I tried, the APTY 21 Cu Ft Car Rooftop Cargo Bag, Waterproof, Lock, Blue stood out. Its heavy-duty 900D PVC fabric and triple-reinforced welded seams provided peace of mind, even in heavy rain. Plus, the anti-slip mat and integrated lock ensured your luggage stays secure while protecting your car from scratches. Unlike others with narrow waterproof flaps or weaker materials, this bag’s robust construction and full waterproof zipper truly stand the test. It offers an excellent balance of size, strength, and security, making it my go-to choice for reliable, fuss-free travel.

Top Recommendation: APTY 21 Cu Ft Car Rooftop Cargo Bag, Waterproof, Lock, Blue

Why We Recommend It: This bag’s heavy-duty 900D anti-abrasion PVC fabric and triple-reinforced welded seams make it far more durable than competitors like Sailnovo or Mockins, which rely on lighter, less tear-resistant fabrics. Its high-quality waterproof zipper and wide velcro flap ensure zero leaks in downpours—something others struggle with. The addition of an anti-slip mat and a lock provides extra security and protects your vehicle, addressing common concerns about theft and scratches. Overall, its combination of size, sturdiness, and weatherproofing makes it the best choice after thorough testing.

Best rooftop luggage carrier: Our Top 5 Picks

• Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier 21 cu ft Waterproof Roof Bag – Best rooftop cargo carrier bag
• Sailnovo 20ft Waterproof Car Roof Cargo Bag with Tie-Down – Best rooftop luggage carrier for road trips
• APTY 21 Cu Ft Car Roof Cargo Bag, Waterproof, Lock, Blue – Best rooftop luggage carrier with lock
• JEGS Rooftop Cargo Carrier for Car Storage – Large Roof – Best rooftop cargo carrier for SUV
• Mockins 35 Cu.Ft. Waterproof Roof Cargo Bag 60″x42″x24 – Best Value

What Are the Different Types of Rooftop Luggage Carriers Available?

The different types of rooftop luggage carriers include various designs and features tailored to specific needs.

1. Rooftop cargo boxes
2. Rooftop cargo bags
3. Rooftop baskets
4. Roof racks without a carrier
5. Hard-shell carriers
6. Soft-shell carriers

Each type of rooftop luggage carrier suits different requirements, allowing users to choose based on their preferences for durability, capacity, and ease of use.

1. Rooftop Cargo Boxes: Rooftop cargo boxes provide a solid, enclosed space for transporting luggage. These boxes are often weather-resistant and secure, making them ideal for long trips. They typically have a locking mechanism to secure the contents. According to a review by Consumer Reports in 2022, cargo boxes can increase storage capacity by up to 16 cubic feet. Popular brands include Thule and Yakima.

2. Rooftop Cargo Bags: Rooftop cargo bags offer a flexible storage option. Made from durable, weather-resistant materials, they can handle varying loads. Their soft structure allows them to conform to irregular shapes. A study published in 2023 by the Outdoor Industry Association points out that cargo bags are lighter and easier to store when not in use compared to hard boxes.

3. Rooftop Baskets: Rooftop baskets are open carriers that can hold both luggage and sports gear. They offer versatility with a design that allows for easy loading and unloading. However, their open nature means that they may not protect contents from the weather. According to research by AutoTrader in 2023, baskets are popular for carrying items like bikes and kayaks.

4. Roof Racks Without a Carrier: Roof racks create a base for adding individual carriers or items directly. They offer the most customization flexibility. Users can mix and match carriers based on their needs, making roof racks a cost-effective solution for various uses. Car and Driver highlighted in 2023 that this option suits frequent travelers who adapt their setups often.

5. Hard-Shell Carriers: Hard-shell carriers offer a sturdy option designed for the protection of valuable items. They typically come with a robust locking mechanism for security. Their rigid structure limits movement, enhancing aerodynamics. According to a Consumer Reports survey, hard-shell carriers are perceived as more secure and safer for fragile items.

6. Soft-Shell Carriers: Soft-shell carriers provide a lightweight and flexible option for transporting gear. They can be easily compressed when empty, making them convenient to store. However, their durability may be less than that of hard-shell options. A survey by Gear Junkie noted that soft-shell carriers often come at a lower price point, appealing to budget-conscious consumers.

What Are the Most Recommended Rooftop Luggage Carriers in 2023?

The most recommended rooftop luggage carriers in 2023 include cargo boxes, cargo bags, and overhead racks designed for various vehicle types.

1. Cargo Boxes
2. Cargo Bags
3. Overhead Racks
4. Vehicle-Specific Roof Racks
5. Soft Shell Carriers
6. Hard Shell Carriers
7. Hitch-Mounted Carriers

The following sections provide detailed insights into each type of rooftop luggage carrier available in 2023.

1. Cargo Boxes: Cargo boxes provide a secure, weather-resistant storage option for added luggage. They are often made from durable plastic and feature locking systems for extra security. The average cargo box can hold between 12 to 20 cubic feet of gear. Models such as the Thule Motion XT and Yakima SkyBox are popular due to their design and ease of installation. According to a review by Outdoor Gear Lab (2023), these boxes improve aerodynamics compared to open carriers.

2. Cargo Bags: Cargo bags are versatile and generally lighter than boxes. They are made from waterproof fabric and can be folded when not in use, saving space. Unlike hard cases, they may not offer as much security since they can be susceptible to theft. Options like the RoofBag and the XCAR Roof Cargo Carrier are widely recommended due to their affordability and ease of installation.

3. Overhead Racks: Overhead racks provide a framework for carrying different cargo types, including bikes or kayaks. They are fixed to the roof and come in various sizes to accommodate various loads. According to a comparison by Cargo Gear (2023), overhead racks are ideal for outdoor enthusiasts who need to transport sports equipment.

4. Vehicle-Specific Roof Racks: Vehicle-specific roof racks are designed for particular vehicle models, ensuring a perfect fit. They are engineered to conform to vehicle specifications, promoting safety and performance. Brands like Rhino-Rack and Thule specialize in this category. This tailored approach often provides enhanced stability compared to universal models.

5. Soft Shell Carriers: Soft shell carriers are perfect for those looking for an easy-to-remove solution. They include zippers and Velcro flaps for securing contents. These bags can expand and compress based on load size. Models from brands like CURT and Rightline Gear are popular for their flexible designs, making them ideal for occasional travelers.

6. Hard Shell Carriers: Hard shell carriers are built for durability and security. They provide maximum protection against weather elements and theft. The premium option in this category often features built-in aerodynamic designs. For instance, the Thule Force XT is known for combining functionality with aesthetics, according to findings by Car and Driver (2023).

7. Hitch-Mounted Carriers: Hitch-mounted carriers are not rooftop options but offer an alternative for additional cargo. They attach to a vehicle’s hitch and are useful for larger items. Models such as the CURT Cargo Carrier and MaxxHaul are recommended for their versatility and easy installation.

Each type of rooftop luggage carrier meets different needs and preferences, allowing consumers to choose the most suitable option for their travel requirements.

How Do Thule Cargo Boxes Compare to Other Brands in Quality and Features?

Thule cargo boxes are known for their high quality and innovative features, often compared to brands such as Yakima, SportRack, and Rhino-Rack. Below is a comparison of these brands based on key aspects:

Brand	Quality	Features	Price Range	Warranty	Weight Capacity
Thule	High durability, premium materials	Easy to install, dual side-opening, aerodynamic design	$$$	Limited lifetime warranty	Up to 450 lbs
Yakima	Good durability, reliable	Quick installation, sturdy design	$$	Limited lifetime warranty	Up to 400 lbs
SportRack	Moderate durability, budget-friendly	Basic features, easy to use	$	1-year warranty	Up to 250 lbs
Rhino-Rack	Good quality, versatile	Wide range of accessories, secure locking	$$	Limited lifetime warranty	Up to 400 lbs

What Key Features Should You Consider When Choosing a Rooftop Luggage Carrier?

When choosing a rooftop luggage carrier, consider the following key features:

1. Type of carrier (soft vs. hard shell)
2. Size and capacity
3. Mounting system compatibility
4. Weather resistance
5. Security features
6. Aerodynamics
7. Weight
8. Price
9. Brand reputation
10. Warranty and support options

Different users may prioritize various features based on needs and preferences. For instance, travelers who frequently encounter harsh weather may emphasize weather resistance, while others may prioritize a lightweight option for fuel efficiency.

1. Type of Carrier:
   The type of carrier refers to the material construction of the rooftop luggage space. Soft carriers are generally made of durable fabric and are lightweight, making them easy to store. Hard shell carriers, on the other hand, offer increased security and protection for fragile items but can be heavier. A 2019 study from Consumer Reports highlights that consumers often choose hard shells for their durability, whereas soft carriers appeal to those who prefer ease of handling.

2. Size and Capacity:
   The size and capacity of the carrier indicate how much luggage it can hold. Common dimensions range from 10 to 20 cubic feet. Buyers should consider the amount of gear needed for their trips. A 2021 survey by RoadTrippers indicated that families often prefer larger models that can accommodate bulky recreational equipment such as skis or canoes.

3. Mounting System Compatibility:
   The mounting system compatibility is crucial for ensuring the carrier fits securely on your vehicle. Options include clamp systems and crossbars. Research from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration emphasizes the importance of a secure fit to prevent accidents or damage. Different vehicles may require specific mounting systems.

4. Weather Resistance:
   Weather resistance protects contents from rain, snow, and dirt. This feature is particularly important in regions with unpredictable weather conditions. Research by the Outdoor Industry Association indicates that 65% of outdoor enthusiasts consider this a top priority when selecting a roof carrier.

5. Security Features:
   Security features include locks and key slots that deter theft. A robust locking mechanism is essential for travelers leaving their vehicles unattended. According to a study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, theft incidents often occur in parking lots, making this feature critical for peace of mind.

6. Aerodynamics:
   Aerodynamics influence fuel efficiency and handling. More streamlined designs create less wind resistance and can reduce drag. A report conducted by the Energy Department in 2020 noted that aerodynamic products can help users save on fuel costs, making them an attractive choice for long-distance travel.

7. Weight:
   Weight impacts fuel economy and ease of installation. Lighter carriers are easier to mount and can lead to better mileage. AAA research signifies that any extra weight can significantly affect overall gas consumption.

8. Price:
   Price varies widely based on quality and features. Options range from budget-friendly models to high-end versions with additional functionalities. According to a 2022 market analysis by Statista, the average price of reputable rooftop carriers is around $300, though investing in a reliable option can lead to better long-term value.

9. Brand Reputation:
   Brand reputation can influence product reliability and performance. Well-known brands often come with verified quality assurance, reflected in customer reviews and ratings. For example, Thule and Yakima are frequently mentioned in discussions regarding the most dependable brands, based on industry reviews in the past several years.

10. Warranty and Support Options:
    Warranty and support ensure coverage against defects and offer help after purchase. A solid warranty reflects confidence in product durability and performance. Research in consumer rights by the Better Business Bureau indicates that products with extensive warranties create greater customer satisfaction.

By considering these features, consumers can select a suitable rooftop luggage carrier that best fits their travel needs and preferences.

How Do You Install and Secure a Rooftop Luggage Carrier Effectively?

To install and secure a rooftop luggage carrier effectively, ensure you follow the proper mounting procedures and utilize securing mechanisms to prevent movement during travel.

First, gather the necessary tools and materials. Common tools include a wrench, screwdriver, and a level. Recommended materials are crossbars and straps or bungee cords.

Next, install the crossbars:
– Position the crossbars on the roof of the vehicle. Ensure they extend beyond the vehicle’s sides for even weight distribution.
– Secure the crossbars using manufacturer guidelines. Generally, this involves tightening bolts or clamps.
– Use a level to ensure that the crossbars are parallel to the ground. This step prevents wind resistance during travel.

Then, place the luggage carrier onto the crossbars:
– Lift the luggage carrier onto the installed crossbars. Ensure it sits evenly.
– Follow any manufacturer instructions for specific alignment requirements. This ensures optimal stability.

After positioning the carrier, secure it:
– Use straps or bungee cords to attach the carrier to the crossbars. Pass these around the carrier and through the crossbars.
– Make sure the straps are tight. Check that there is no slack, as this can cause movement during travel.
– Implement additional securing methods such as additional tie-downs or locks based on the carrier type and luggage weight.

Finally, conduct a safety check:
– Perform a test drive at low speeds. Listen for any unusual noises that may indicate movement.
– Inspect the carrier after the test drive. Ensure the straps are still tight and adjust if needed.
– Regularly check the carrier during long trips to ensure it remains secure.

Utilizing these steps will effectively install and secure a rooftop luggage carrier, enhancing the safety and stability of your cargo during your travels.

What Maintenance Tips Will Extend the Life of Your Rooftop Luggage Carrier?

To extend the life of your rooftop luggage carrier, regular maintenance is essential. Following specific care tips will help ensure it remains functional and secure for years to come.

1. Clean the carrier regularly
2. Inspect for damage or wear
3. Check mounting hardware
4. Store properly when not in use
5. Avoid overloading
6. Use a protective cover
7. Ensure proper aerodynamics

To effectively understand these maintenance tips, each point requires detailed insights into best practices.

1. Cleaning the Carrier Regularly: Regularly cleaning your rooftop luggage carrier is crucial. Dirt, debris, and chemicals can cause damage over time. Use mild soap and water to prevent any scratches or deterioration of the material.

2. Inspect for Damage or Wear: Inspecting your carrier for damage or wear is vitally important. Look for cracks, rust, or signs of wear in the lid or hinges. A quick check monthly can prevent small issues from becoming bigger problems.

3. Check Mounting Hardware: Checking the mounting hardware ensures your carrier stays securely attached to your vehicle. Tighten bolts and screws regularly. Loose hardware can lead to accidents or loss of the carrier during transit.

4. Store Properly When Not in Use: Proper storage of the carrier when not in use helps maintain its condition. If possible, store it indoors to protect it from UV rays and harsh weather. Covering it with a tarp can also provide added protection.

5. Avoid Overloading: Avoiding overloading your rooftop luggage carrier is essential for its longevity. Excess weight can strain the carrier and your vehicle’s roof. Always follow the manufacturer’s weight limit guidelines.

6. Use a Protective Cover: Using a protective cover can shield your carrier from elements and scratches. A fitted cover helps keep it clean and reduces the risk of damage from sun exposure or harsh weather.

7. Ensure Proper Aerodynamics: Ensuring your carrier’s proper aerodynamics can improve fuel efficiency and reduce noise. Position your carrier correctly and choose a design that minimizes drag.

By following these maintenance tips, you can maximize the lifespan and performance of your rooftop luggage carrier.

How Do Rooftop Luggage Carriers Affect Fuel Efficiency and Vehicle Stability?

Rooftop luggage carriers can negatively affect fuel efficiency and vehicle stability due to increased aerodynamic drag and changes in weight distribution.

Aerodynamic drag: Rooftop carriers can increase wind resistance. According to a study by Hucho (2016), this additional drag can reduce fuel efficiency by up to 10%. Vehicles are less streamlined when a carrier is added, leading to decreased airflow and greater power needed for movement.

Weight distribution: Rooftop carriers raise the center of gravity of a vehicle. This elevation can negatively influence handling and stability, particularly during sharp turns or sudden maneuvers. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) notes that higher centers of gravity increase rollover risks.

Additional weight: The carrier itself adds weight. Heavier loads can negatively impact fuel economy. A study from the Washington State Department of Transportation (2018) indicated that every additional 100 pounds can decrease fuel efficiency by about 1%.

Influence on handling: As weight shifts in the vehicle, steering response may be affected. This can lead to reduced control, especially in adverse conditions such as rain or ice, as reported by the International Journal of Automotive Technology (Kwon et al., 2021).

Impact on braking: Increased weight and higher centers of gravity can lengthen stopping distances. According to a report by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), it’s crucial to account for these factors for overall vehicle safety while using rooftop carriers.

Collectively, these factors indicate that rooftop luggage carriers can substantially affect both fuel efficiency and vehicle stability.

Related Post:

• Best luggage rooftop cargo bag
• Best luggage for domestic travel
• Best tech cabin luggage
• Best cabin size luggage
• Best device for tracking luggage